So.
Paki girl, born and brought up in that country, so on and so forth… fed on dreams of being a high-flying lawyer, academic, whatever-you-want-to-call-it. Went to the US, brimming with ambition. Did a BA in Political Science. Applied for a PhD. Directly after, got married, moved to the Middle East, and became a housewife. FYI for all the shocked feminists around the world: I like it. Big time.
I wash and dry clothes. I iron them. Fold them, hang them up. Wash dishes, dry them, put them away. Clean a bit. And I cook – chicken, rice, bread… All that home-comfort sort of stuff. And I enjoy that.
For those of you out there who thought this blog was going to be about a Pakistani girl, giving a fresh perspective on life in the Arab world, and are disappointed now because they find instead that it’s about a random housewife… You’re both right and wrong. I will talk about being in the Arab world, and life here (in Bahrain for the most part, mind you) bit by bit. But this blog is about MY life in Bahrain. Me, a Pakistani girl… In the Arab World. So you will get a bit of what my life is about as well. And currently, I’m a housewife. See?
The intro note was just for you to know the basics. Additionally, I told you quite frankly that I like being a homemaker for now, to fend off all the shocked statements from people who CLEARLY expected ‘more’ from me. So there.
But anyhoo… I’m sure you’ll hear about my unique feminist viewpoint if you keep coming back to this blog over a period of time. Lucky you, right? But in the meantime…
In this past month, I traveled to Dubai in the UAE, and then moved to Bahrain. Reading being a passion of sorts for me, in both these countries, I went to bookstores. One in Dubai – Borders for that matter, an international chain that has bookstores around the world. In Bahrain – Virgin. A renowned American brand, I believe. One similarity in both these bookstores struck me… Neither bookstore seems to have a staff that can really read and write English.
I meet the staff. I do a double take. I take a quick look at the shelves around me, just to make sure once more… Yes, it seems that the books stocked here are, for the most part, in the colonial language that overcame half the world. Then why have salespeople who have no command over it? The irony of it all is more than I can immediately grasp.
Conversation 1 (Borders, Dubai):
Me: Excuse me, do you have the book “the elegance of the hedgehog”?
(Pause. The Indian salesperson (SP) looks at his computer screen. I have time to admire his red tikka, and the myriads of gold (or gold-plated) jewelry dripping from his neck and his wrists in chain and coils.)
SP: (brazen, no apology or embarrassment in tone) How do you spell ‘Elegance’?
Me: (dumbfounded, then recollecting myself) Uhh… E – L – E – G – A – N – C – E.
SP: (still unmoved) G – E?
Me: G – A… N – C – E
(Pause again. SP typing something, then staring at the screen)
SP: How do you spell Hedgehog?
Here we go again…
Conversation 2 (Virgin, Bahrain):
Me: Excuse me, do you have the book “the elegance of the hedgehog”?
SP: How do you spell ‘Elegance’?
This old song again. I’m used to it by now. I suck it up and say it.
Me: E-L-E-G-A-N-C-E
SP: Is Hedgehog together or separate?
I take his statement to mean that he wants to know whether ‘Hedgehog’ is one word or two. He’s nearly as linguistically disabled in the English department as the guy in Dubai, but I have to give him credit… At least he’s faster.
Me: It’s together. One word.
Of course, you will not be surprised to know that neither bookstore stocked the book. I’m ordering it off the Internet now.
But really, folks… What’s the deal with these salespersons? If they’re so interested in working for a bookstore (which I highly doubt, by the way) then why not work for one where they actually have a chance at deciphering one of the book covers? A hindi bookstore perhaps… Marathi. Gujrati. Malayalam. Even Urdu or Arabic, please… But a bookstore where these people will be of use. NOT ENGLISH.
When I was in the US, the local Barnes & Nobles had a ‘staff picks’ section – a section of books that were handpicked by individual staff members as their favorites. A book would be displayed, and underneath it, it would have the name of the staff member who picked it out, followed by his or her comment: “this book is great – it talks about such-and-such thing in a really charming, quirky way. I wish there were more of it!” And so on… At least I got a sense that people in this bookstore know the language, and know the books. But in these bookstores here in the Middle East… So far… No Cigar.
Ironically enough, I noted that the Borders bookstore had a stall ‘Borders recommends’. Initially, I wondered if these were staff picks as well, or picks sent ‘from up above,’ as there was no personal note as in the case of the Barnes & Nobles in the US. But one meeting with the staff, and I know the answer… It’s a wonder that they were able to put the books picked out under the correct signs. Well, that’s a bit harsh… After all, I believe they can follow it out by matching letter to letter. So yeah…
From now on, I do my book shopping here silently, without question. I dread asking for another book. In the meantime… Let’s hope for salespeople more suited to their jobs in bookstores in the Middle East. Please.
Loved reading your blog, really funny part about the salesperson intraction , but i guess they are just there for the money paying job and not to be a librarian , and perhaps the bookstore management didnt have much variety to choose from for hiring, which is good they are not discriminatory , here is to hoping that the maybe the salespeople will eventually develop an interest in the things they are selling and get to learn the language too, Natasha share more about the books you are reading too because after graduation really have the time to devouring as much of them as i can get my hands on so fill me up with ur insightful reviews....cheers to your house-wifedom!
ReplyDeleteNuts! mahgul, zoha, elaiha and mahnum sitting here and we are just appalled! what is this elitist attitude towards people not knowing english. they are working there for the money, nothing else, and that part about how they matched the books to the staff picks being a sign of being slightly competent is very mean. stop being such a hater, look for the books yourselves.
ReplyDeletei think u have an absolutely amazing flair for writing ....yes yu must share your reading with all of us ...
ReplyDeleteTime to write another blog entry and... EMAIL ME UR WEDDING PICS YAAR! :)
ReplyDeleteluv ya and miss ya! :)
To Kashraf:
ReplyDeleteHey :-) Sorry for the late reply, but... Have been kind of crazy busy lately. Anyway, about books - I've been reading the following:
Beatrice and Virgil. by Yann Martel - sort of disturbing. But definitely interesting... It's the kind of book that haunts you for a couple of days after you read it. It's about the holocaust, and a fictional representation of it through animals.
Service with a Smile: as always, P.G. Wodehouse is a charmer. This book is from his Blandings Castle series, with a bit of Uncle Fred mixed in. I really like the series... Particularly the Psmith book. I'm hoping to find more on him soon.
A Pair of Blue Eyes: on a completely different note, we have Thomas Hardy here. I've always been fond of Hardy. His books seem to me to touch a very real, very human aspect of all our emotions... Nothing is black and white, and sometimes we make such simple mistakes, which lead to so much. A very simplistic way of describing Hardy, but anyway... All I can say is I like the book.
The Double Comfort Safari Club: this book is by Alexander McCall Smith. It's usually listed in the mystery section abroad... In the fiction section otherwise. This is actually the 11th book in the series entitled The No. 1 Ladies Detective Agency, all about the life and job of a female private detective in Botswana, Africa. I've read the prior ten, and would recommend all eleven to anybody... They make for light, interesting reading.
The Midnight Folk: this is a kid's book, based on magic and treasure and pirates and the demands of honour. I read kids' books from time to time... They help keep me sane and not to take myself too seriously. I don't know if you do the same, but still... Nice book, definitely fun.
Salmon Fishing in the Yemen: This was like a political comedy, and definitely interesting - a satire on British comedy with a nod toward the Middle East. I might not have loved loved loved it, but I thought it was good. Worth a read.
Letter to my daughter: this book is by the famous American poet, Maya Angelou. It's literally like a letter of advice, composed in bits and pieces, by the poet (who is a quite elderly woman). I hate to say this, but I didn't really find it worth it. There were some interesting stories in there about respecting other people's cultural viewpoints and not thinking you have all the answers, but that's about it. Not much to buy the book for.
So yeah... These are some of the more noteworthy things I have been reading.
In the meantime... Congratulations on your graduation!
To Mahnum, Zoha, Mahgul and Elaiha:
ReplyDeleteI'm not being an elitist, it's just a simple fact... Having a person who has no command over the English language working in an English language bookstore is as ridiculous as having someone who has no command over the Arabic language working in an Arabic language bookstore. My blog was not about the superiority of one language over another, it was about not being competent to work where you're working at all!
And yeah, I am looking for the books myself. Don't seem to have a choice now, do I?
hmmm very interesting list , now that is what i was looking
ReplyDeleteYann Martel has overall disappointed me a great deal , after the expectations built after "Life of Pi" , none of his works even come close to that one, i recently read another "Life of the Roccametious" or smthg by the same, very dissapointing not going to read "Beatrice and Virgil" though.
Hardy is favorite of mine as well and meaning to read "Pair of Blue Eyes" for a long time , will definitely try this one out. A suggestion on a similar genre try Thackeray' "Vanity Fair" if you haven't read it already, I am really enjoying his style and sensibility, especially the humour. I discovered him through the movie "Vanity Fair" with casting of Reese Witherspoon in it and absolutely loved the book.
On a tangent ...seen any good movies?
"Salmon fishing in the yemen" seems interesting will try and a get a hold of the book, the thing about political satires they have to be written well and only quick witted ones go down well me ....read "Exploding Mangoes" ? really enjoyed it , would recommend "White Tiger" to anyone interested in political comedy with a splash of biting sarcasm.
P.G woodhouse always reserve for a side read...
Try "Peacock Throne" really enlightening as far as subcontinent history is concerned and is not you typical boring history type either.
Love
K.Ashraf
Have had Vanity Fair lying about in my bookshelf at home for some time, but never got around it... Will definitely look into it now inshallah. It's great to find someone who's interested in these old books like I am... Give Middlemarch a look if you haven't already done so, as well as The Mill on the Floss. Both excellent books. I will definitely see if I can get Peacock Throne.
ReplyDeleteMovies - well, I've seen Robin Hood (not bad), Salt (really stupid), despicable me (quite cute) and Inception (quite good, and interesting). So yeah...
Do keep sharing books with me...
Take care,
Natasha
you never put a guy with matches in a bunker full of dynamite... i probably do not have the necessary details regarding your experiences to my knowledge, but i believe in oppressive cultures, you really wouldnt want to put people who can make use of the books around them... literature is like a dormant volcano--you know it really won't cause any damage, but you keep an eye on it regardless.. books can educate you--not in the platonic sense of the word--they can liberate... in cultures where you wouldnt really want the locals to have a free will, you wouldnt want literate people hanging around with potentially 'provocative' (re: politically) material around them... what if one of the SPs gets bored and starts reading?
ReplyDeleteyou could simply NOT have bookshops, but then how would you show to the 'civilized' allies that you are a 'free' nation...?
just some random thoughts... i stumbled across your blog today and have gone through most of your posts-- you should write more often...
as a parting note, i recommend reading "Nella Last's War" by Nella Last...
oh and of course, watch 'the fountain' & 'seven pounds' (sorry but i've taken the liberty to make suggestions from your last comment)...